Are our Indian medical graduates equipped and informed to handle end of life dilemmas?

T S Gugapriya, N Vinay Kumar

Abstract


Introduction: Euthanasia stands as the much debated, controversial and legally questionable end of life dilemma encountered by health care professionals globally. In India, currently active euthanasia has been debated for granting legal sanction. Yet, the health care professionals especially the medical graduates were not exposed to these ethical end of life dilemmas in their formative years. This scenario calls for an analysis into their understanding of this issue, how they want to handle such dilemmas and whether they had adequate exposure and training to handle such end of life dilemmas in their curriculum.

Methodology: A questionnaire with three segments of 9, 5and 6 questions each was administered to 100 medical graduates who were enrolled voluntarily for this study. The collected data were analysed by descriptive statistics.

Results: Only 53% showed awareness about euthanasia. Among them only 17% among were aware of physician assisted death. The third year graduates had finite idea about this concept among all years studied. The study found that the medical graduates wanted legalisation of euthanasia. Only 37% opined that if legalised they might administer if needed on their patients. Personal belief was cited as the primary reason for hesitancy to administer euthanasia. Less than 50% only were aware of right of the patient to decide to have euthanasia. Majority reported that the duration allotted for formal teaching of these were minimal and restricted to only second professional year.

Conclusion: End of life ethical dilemmas do exist and this study pointed the clear gap in understanding, implementation of medical graduates about these concepts. The study stresses the need for exposing the medical graduates to these bioethical concepts in their curriculum in a more active way.

Keywords: Euthanasia, Physician assisted death.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Grassi L, Magnani K, Ercolani M. Attitudes toward euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide among Italian primary care physicians. J Pain Symptom Manage 1999; 17 (3):188-96.

Vilela LP, Caramelli P. Knowledge of the definition of euthanasia: study with doctors and caregivers of Alzheimer’s disease patients. Rev Assoc Med Bras 2009;55(3):263-7.

Emanuel EJ, Fairclough D, Clarridge BC, Blum D, Bruera E, Penley WC, et al. Attitudes and Practices of U.S. Oncologists regarding Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide. Ann Int Med 2000;133:527-32.

Sklansky M. Neonatal euthanasia: moral considerations and criminal liability. J Med Ethics 2001;27(1):5-11.

Du Gas BW. Introduction to patient care- A Comprehensive approach to Nursing. 4 ed. New Delhi: Elsevier publications; 2006.p 694-5.

Euthanasia. Available from: URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/euthanasia.

Chandara Russell. Christian Ethics. 1997; 2nd Edition: 140-7.

Das. Sohen. Christian Ethics and Indian Ethos.2004;5 Edition : 171

Porter T, Johnson P, Warren NA. Bioethical issues concerning death: death, dying, and end-of-life rights. Crit Care Nurs Q 2005;28:85-92.

Babqi A. Legal issues in end-of-life care: perspectives from Saudi Arabia and United States. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2009;26:119-27.

Chao DV, Chan NY, Chan WY. Euthanasia revisited. Fam Pract 2002;19:128–34.

British Broadcasting Corporation. Ethics Guide. Euthanasia. 2014. Available from:http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/overview/introduction.shtml.

Ebrahimi N. The ethics of euthanasia. Aust Med Stud J. 2012; 3:73–5.

VKS, Basu S, Sarkhel S. Euthanasia: An Indian perspective. Indian J Psychiatry 2012;54:177–83.

Ward BJ, Tate PA. Attitudes among NHS doctors to requests for euthanasia. BMJ 1994;308:1332.

Sneha Kamath et.al. Attitude towards euthanasia among Doctors in a Territory Hospital. Indian J Palliat Care 2011;17(3):197–201.

Sonu Hangma Subba, Varun Khullar, Yusra Latafat, Khushboo Chawla, Apoorva Nirmal, Tanvi Chaudhary. Doctors’ Attitude towards Euthanasia: A Cross-sectional Study. J Assoc Physicians India 2016;64:44-4.

Maria Therese A, Rukumani J, Pon Princess Mano, Ponrani & Nirmala. A study to assess the level of attitude towards euthanasia among health personnel. NUJHS 2014;4(4):18-23.

Ramírez-Rivera J, Cruz J, Jaume-Anselmi F. Euthanasia, assisted suicide and end-of-life care: attitudes of students, residents and attending physicians. P R Health Sci J 2006;25(4):325-9.

Cohen J, van Delden J, Mortier F, Löfmark R, Norup M, Cartwright C, et al. Influence of physicians’ life stances on attitudes to end-of-life decisions and actual end-of-life decision-making in six countries. J Med Ethics 2008;34(4):247-53.

Anielli Pinheiro, Marcelo Arruda Nakazone, Fernanda Silva Leal, Marcela Augusta Souza Pinhel, Dorotéia Rossi Silva Souza, et al. Medical Students’ Knowledge about End-of-life Decision-Making. Revista Brasileira De Educação Médica 2011;35(2):171–6.

Shah A, Mushtaq A. The right to live or die? A perspective on voluntary euthanasia. Pak J Med Sci 2014;30:1159–60.

Schicktanz S, Raz A, Shalev C. The cultural context of patient's autonomy and doctor's duty: passive euthanasia and advance directives in Germany and Israel. Med Health Care Philos.2010, 13:363–369. Shekhar S, Goel A: Euthanasia: India's position in the global scenario. Am J Hosp Palliat Care 2013;30:628–31.

Abbas SQ, Abbas Z, Macaden S. Attitudes towards euthanasia and physician assisted suicide among Pakistani and Indian doctors: a survey. Indian J Palliat Care 2008;14:71-4.

Lee MA, Nelson HD, Tilden VP, Ganzini L, Schmidt TA, Tolle SW. Legalizing Assisted Suicide — Views of Physicians in Oregon. N Engl J Med 1996;334:310-5.

Seale C. Legalization of euthanasia and physician assisted suicide: survey of doctors’ attitude. Palliat Med 2009;23:205- 12.

Fekete S, Osvath P, Jegesy A. Attitudes of Hungarian students and nurses to physician assisted suicide. J Med Ethics 2002;28(2):126.

Ramírez-Rivera J, Rodríguez R, Otero Igaravidez Y. Attitudes toward euthanasia, assisted suicide and termination of life-sustaining treatment of Puerto Rican medical students, medical residents, and faculty. Bol Asoc Med P R 2000;92(1-3):18-21.

Akabayashi A, Slingsby BT, Nagao N, Kai I, Sato H. An eight-year follow-up national study of medical school and general hospital ethics committees in Japan. BMC Med Ethics 2007;8:8.

Marini MC, Neuenschwander H, Stiefel F. Attitudes toward euthanasia and physician assisted suicide: a survey among medical students, oncology clinicians, and palliative care specialists. Palliat Support Care 2006;4(3):251-5.

Gruber PC, Gomersall CD, Joynt GM, Lee A, Tang PY, Young AS, et al. Changes in medical students’ attitudes towards end-of-life decisions across different years of medical training. J Gen Intern Med 2008;23(10):1608-1614.

Medical council of India. Competency Based Under Graduate Curriculum. Attitude, Ethics and Communication (AETCOM). https://www.mciindia.org/CMS/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/AETCOM_book.pdf (accessed 18 november2019)

Khan F, Pramod K L. Awareness and perception towards euthanasia among students of Arts and Science College MedPulse – Int Med J 2017;4(7):841-5.

Nick Α. Bakalis, Nanouri Filippia, Ntzoufra Maria, Panagiotis Kiekkas. The attitude of Greek student nurses toward Euthanasia. J Nurs Educ Pract 2014;4(1):237-46.

Biondo CA, Silva MJ, Secoo LM. Dysthanasia, euthanasia, othotanasia:the perception of nurses working in intensive care units and care implications. Rev Latin-Am 2009;17(5)613-9.

Özler H. Nurses’ Approach to euthanasia and a case study from Osmangazi University hospital. Master Thesis, Osmangazi University Institute Health Sci Deontol Depart, Bursa, 2001.

Giakis Ν, Merkouris Α, Polichronopoulou Ε, & Adali Α. The attitude of nursing staff about euthanasia. Nosileftiki 2005;44(1):84-91

Khan MA, Javaid A, Sajjad H, Ahmad F, Khattak A, Khan N, Adnan MAR. Clinicians approach to euthanasia in the province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. J Postgrad Med Inst 2015;29(3):184-8.

Aliya Bulut. The opinions about euthanasia among students in elderly care department of vocational school of health services at Bingol University. Med Sci Int Med J 2017;1-7.

Annets D. Comments from Voluntary Euthanasia Society, In: Views on end-of-life issues from around the world. Int J Palliat Nurs 2004;10:248-9.

Bisset M. Euthanasia is not an adequate response to suffering at the end of life, In: Views on end-of-life issues from around the world. Int J Palliat Nurs 2004;10:253.

Marcoux, Hubert. Should physicians be open to euthanasia? Canadian Family Physician.2010; 56(4):321 – 323. http://www.cfp.ca/cgi/content/full/56/4/321

Sjöstrand M, Helgesson G, Eriksson S, Juth N. Autonomy-based arguments against physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia: a critique. Med Health Care Philos 2013;16(2):225-30. doi: 10.1007/s11019-011-9365-5.

Jenny Ko. Legalization of euthanasia violates the principles of competence, autonomy, and beneficence. BCMJ 2010;52(2):92.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.